25 Best Pizza Deliveries in NYC: The Ultimate 2026 Guide
Ordering pizza in New York is an art form. This 2026 guide selects the 25 best spots that guarantee high-quality delivery, from classic Joe's cheese slices to spicy Prince Street squares, ensuring you eat like a local, even in your hotel room
🍕 25 Best Pizza Deliveries in NYC: The Ultimate 2026 Guide 🛵
In New York City, pizza isn’t just a meal; it’s an emergency service. In 2026, with the rise of high-quality delivery options, you no longer need to brave 2-hour lines to eat the city’s best slices. The legends have adapted, and now the perfect dough comes to your door.
Whether you are looking for a classic foldable slice, a spicy square Sicilian pie, or a gourmet truffle experience, NYC’s delivery bikes will bring it to you. However, you need to know where to order to avoid the dreaded “soggy pizza.”
We at AZ New York have tested the delivery times and crust integrity. Here are the 25 best pizza delivery options in New York City.
💡 Tips for Perfect NYC Pizza Delivery
- Always Reheat: Even the best delivery cools down. Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C) and pop the slices in (directly on the rack if possible) for 2-3 minutes. The crust will come back to life.
- Watch the Apps: Legendary spots like Lucali or John’s of Bleecker often appear only on specific apps (like Uber Eats or Grubhub) or use exclusive services like Caviar.
- Order “Well Done”: When ordering delivery, request your pizza “well done.” This ensures it leaves the shop crispier and withstands the travel time in the cardboard box better.
The 25 Best Deliveries (Verified 2026 List)
Selected for pizza quality and delivery reliability.
| Pizzeria | What to Order (Highlight) | Zone / Main App |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Joe’s Pizza 👑 | Plain Cheese. The absolute benchmark. Travels surprisingly well. | Manhattan / UberEats |
| 2. Prince Street Pizza 🌶️ | Spicy Spring. Thick dough and crispy pepperoni are perfect for delivery. | SoHo / Caviar |
| 3. Rubirosa 🍝 | Vodka Pizza. Thin crust, creamy vodka sauce. A cult classic. | NoLita / Caviar |
| 4. L’Industrie Pizzeria 🏆 | Burrata Slice. The trendiest pizza of 2026. Always arrives fresh. | West Village / BK |
| 5. Scarr’s Pizza 🌾 | Original Cheese. House-milled flour. Authentic old-school flavor. | LES / UberEats |
| 6. John’s of Bleecker 🏛️ | Whole Pie Only. Coal oven. Only whole pies, no slices. | West Village / Grubhub |
| 7. Lucali 🦄 | Plain Pie. The hardest to get, but possible via apps at off-peak times. | Brooklyn / UberEats |
| 8. Mama’s TOO! 🔥 | Cacio e Pepe. Square, burnt and caramelized edges. | UWS / DoorDash |
| 9. Emily 🍯 | The Colony. Detroit style, hot honey, and pepperoni. Divine. | West Village / BK |
| 10. Roberta’s 🐝 | Bee Sting. The pizza that put Bushwick on the dining map. | Brooklyn / Caviar |
| 11. Paulie Gee’s Slice 🍕 | Hellboy. Pepperoni with Mike’s Hot Honey. | Greenpoint / Seamless |
| 12. Di Fara Pizza 🌿 | Classic Pie. Fresh basil cut with scissors. A legend. | Midwood / UberEats |
| 13. L&B Spumoni 🟥 | The Square. Sauce on top of the cheese. Fluffy brioche-like dough. | Brooklyn / DoorDash |
| 14. Ribalta 🇮🇹 | Neapolitan. Authentic Neapolitan pizza, light and airy. | Union Square / Apps |
| 15. Kesté 🌾 | Gluten Free. Probably the best gluten-free pizza in the city. | FiDi / Apps |
| 16. Motorino 🥬 | Brussels Sprout. Brussels sprout pizza with pancetta. Surprisingly good. | East Village / UWS |
| 17. Lombardi’s 🕰️ | Clam Pie. America’s First Pizzeria (1905). Historic. | SoHo / Own Delivery |
| 18. Patsy’s (Harlem) 🌑 | Coal Oven. Original coal oven. Thin and charred crust. | East Harlem / Apps |
| 19. Best Pizza 🤍 | White Pie. Ricotta, caramelized onions, and sesame seeds on the crust. | Williamsburg / Apps |
| 20. Upside Pizza 🍄 | Mushroom. Sourdough crust. Intense flavor. | Midtown / Apps |
| 21. Artichoke Basille 🥛 | Artichoke. Creamy artichoke sauce. Heavy and delicious. | Various Locations / Apps |
| 22. Fini Pizza 🍋 | White Slice. Served with lemon zest. Modern and fresh. | Williamsburg / Apps |
| 23. Made in NY Pizza 🏙️ | Pepperoni Square. Consistent, greasy in a good way, and fast. | UWS / Apps |
| 24. Una Pizza Napoletana ⭐ | Margherita. Gourmet, light dough. Available only on specific days. | LES / Apps |
| 25. Sauce Pizzeria 🍅 | Sauce Slice. Comes with an extra cup of sauce for dipping. | East Village / Apps |
See also in this category (Gastronomy & Food)
Complete your NYC culinary experience with our other guides:
- 25 Best Pizza Slices in New York: The Ultimate 2026 Guide
- 25 Best Burger Spots in NYC: The Ultimate 2026 Guide
- 25 Best Steakhouses in NYC: The Ultimate 2026 Guide
Post Summary
Ordering pizza in New York is an art form. This 2026 guide selects the 25 best spots that guarantee high-quality delivery, from classic Joe’s cheese slices to spicy Prince Street squares, ensuring you eat like a local, even in your hotel room.
25 Best Keywords (Tags)
Best Pizza Delivery NYC 2026, Pizza Delivery New York, Joe’s Pizza UberEats, Prince Street Pizza Delivery, L’Industrie Pizzeria Delivery, Gluten Free Pizza NYC Delivery, Best Brooklyn Pizza Delivery, Late Night Pizza NYC, John’s of Bleecker Street Grubhub, Rubirosa Vodka Pizza at Home, Scarr’s Pizza Delivery, Di Fara Pizza UberEats, Pepperoni Pizza NYC,
Emily Pizza Burger Delivery, Roberta’s Bee Sting, Mama’s TOO Delivery, Cheap Pizza NYC Delivery, Best Food App NYC, Sicilian Pizza Delivery, Neapolitan Pizza NYC Delivery, Where to Order Pizza Manhattan, Best Italian Restaurants NYC, High Quality Pizza NYC, Fast Food NYC Delivery, NYC Pizza Guide 2026.
25 Best Bagel Shops in New York: The Ultimate 2026 Guide
Understanding Trust and Estate Planning with NYC’s Top Legal Experts
NYC’s Top 15 Private Wealth Management Firms
